He told the judge his receipts were stolen from his car. More than once. He still lost every dollar of about $54,000 in deductions.
At year end, many clients ask me whether they can still find extra deductions, credits and loopholes. In my opinion, tax planning starts with being organized. Most tax savings can't happen without solid records of your income and expenses. A 2026 Tax Court case shows what happens when those records are missing, and what you can do so it doesn't happen to you.
The case: Lee v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-43
Sang Hun Lee is an engineer who lived in California in 2018. His main job was as an in-person contractor for a company in Morgan Hill, near San Jose, where he had worked since mid-2017. He also had side work. During the week he stayed near San Jose, renting a room or staying with friends, and on weekends he went home to Los Angeles.
He did not file a 2018 return. The IRS prepared a substitute for return for him, using only his main job's pay of $84,111 and the standard deduction. A substitute for return gives you no business expenses at all. The IRS sent a notice of deficiency for $22,383, plus additions to tax for filing late, paying late and not making estimated tax payments.
In Tax Court, he claimed about $54,000 of business expenses: meals, lodging, commuting, his car, computer parts and more. His proof was bank statements showing dates and amounts, and two spreadsheets he made after the year was over. The spreadsheets put labels on charges, such as "meal" at a barbecue restaurant or "computer parts" at an electronics store. He had no receipts. He said he kept them in his car and the car was broken into several times.
The court disallowed every deduction and kept all three penalties.
Are bank statements enough to prove business expenses? Why they were not in Lee
Deductions are a matter of legislative grace. Section 162 allows ordinary and necessary business expenses, section 262 says personal expenses are not deductible, and section 6001 requires you to keep records that show which is which. The burden is on you.
A bank statement proves that money left your account. It does not prove what you bought, why you bought it, or how it connects to your business. A label you add a year later does not fix that.
Under the old Cohan rule (Cohan v. Commissioner, 2d Cir. 1930), a court can sometimes estimate an expense when there is credible evidence to build on. Here the court said it had no basis to estimate. It can't just guess. For travel, vehicles and other listed property, the law is stricter still. Section 274(d) overrides Cohan. Estimates are not allowed at all. You need adequate records or other evidence that backs up your own statement.
The court also noted that buying lunch for coworkers is a personal expense. And while it did not need to decide the point, it pointed to the one-year rule: a work location that lasts more than a year is not temporary. That means weekday meals and lodging near a long-term job are usually personal, even if your family lives somewhere else.
What each record must show
Treasury Regulation section 1.274-5 lists the elements for travel and vehicle expenses, and they make a good checklist for every expense:
- Amount: what you paid, from a receipt or invoice, not just the bank total.
- Time: the date of the expense, or the dates you left and returned for a trip.
- Place: where you spent the money or where you traveled.
- Business purpose: why you spent it. What job, what client, what reason.
- Business relationship: for meals with others, who was there and how they relate to your business.
- Made at or near the time: a log, calendar entry or note written when it happened, not rebuilt at tax time.
For travel and vehicle expenses, the regulation generally also requires documentary evidence, such as a receipt, for any lodging and for other expenses of $75 or more.
What counts as good records, by expense type
| Expense | Good records | What usually falls short |
|---|---|---|
| Meals | Itemized receipt, plus a note of who attended and the business discussed. Business meals are generally only 50% deductible. | A card charge at a restaurant with no names or purpose |
| Travel and lodging | Hotel folio, airfare receipts, and a note of the dates, destination and business reason for the trip | Rent paid in cash with no lease or landlord statement |
| Vehicle | A mileage log kept as you drive: date, destination, purpose and miles, plus odometer readings at the start and end of the year | Total miles estimated at year end |
| Equipment and computers | Invoice showing the item, the date bought and placed in service, proof of payment, and the share of business use | An electronics store charge labeled "computer parts" later |
| Home office | Measurements of the space, photos showing it is used regularly and only for business, plus rent or mortgage, utility and insurance statements | A guess at square footage with no bills |
How to rebuild lost or stolen records
Losing records does not end the conversation. The regulations allow a reasonable reconstruction when records are lost through circumstances beyond your control, such as a fire, flood or other casualty. In Boyd v. Commissioner, 122 T.C. 305 (2004), the Tax Court said a taxpayer in that position can use other credible evidence. Mr. Lee did not offer any. His own word was not enough. Here is the order I usually follow:
- Document the loss. Get a copy of the police report, fire report or insurance claim, with the date.
- List what you are trying to prove. Go through bank and card statements and mark each charge you believe was a business expense.
- Ask vendors for duplicates. Many stores, hotels, airlines and suppliers can reprint invoices or receipts, or send an account history.
- Pull itemized card detail. Card issuers and online accounts often show the merchant, date and sometimes the items bought.
- Get third-party letters. Landlords or hosts can confirm rent and dates. Employers or clients can confirm where you worked and when.
- Rebuild mileage from other records. Use calendars, emails, job tickets, invoices and toll or parking records to show each trip, then calculate the miles.
- Write a summary that ties it together. For each expense: the amount, date, place, business purpose and the document that supports it.
The goal is a file where every number points to something other than your memory.
Act early, not at trial
If the IRS filed a return for you, I usually suggest filing a real original return with your actual expenses as soon as possible, and building the proof file early. In my experience, these issues are best addressed at the exam or Appeals stage. By the time a case is in court, it is late, and a judge can only work with the evidence in front of them.
"Too busy" is not reasonable cause
Mr. Lee argued that he was too busy to file. He had several jobs and a long commute. The court said that work demands, even extreme ones, are not reasonable cause for filing or paying late under section 6651.
Real reasons, such as serious illness, a death in the family or a disaster, may count if you can show with dates that they actually kept you from filing. The opinion mentions that his father had died in 2015, but he did not argue that as a reason for 2018, and the court did not consider it.
First-time abatement may also be worth checking. It can remove late filing and late payment penalties for one year if you generally have a clean penalty history for the prior three years and have filed all currently required returns. Someone with several unfiled years may not qualify until those are filed. The estimated tax penalty under section 6654 is different. It has essentially no reasonable cause relief and is not covered by first-time abatement.
A simple weekly habit
Once a week, set aside 15 minutes:
- Save the receipts from the week, as photos or scans, somewhere other than your car.
- Next to each one, write a line about the business purpose: who, what and why.
- Update your mileage log with the week's business trips.
- For any travel, note why you went to that area and how the hotel or meals related to the business and not a personal getaway.
That small habit is what turns a bank statement line into a deduction that can hold up.
FAQ
Are credit card statements enough?
Usually not by themselves. A statement shows the merchant, date and amount. It doesn't show what you bought or why. Pair it with the receipt and a note of the business purpose.
Can I use a mileage app?
Yes, and it can be one of the easiest ways to keep a log made at the time. Most apps record the date, route and miles automatically. Make sure you also record the business purpose of each trip, and keep your odometer readings for the start and end of the year.
How long do I keep records?
Generally at least 3 years from the date you filed or the due date, whichever is later. Keep them 6 years if you left out more than 25% of your income, 7 years for a bad debt or worthless securities deduction, and at least 4 years for employment tax records. Records for property, such as equipment or a building, should be kept until the limitation period runs out for the year you sell or dispose of it. If you never filed, there is no time limit. My record retention guide has the federal, New York, New Jersey and Connecticut rules in one place.
If you're not sure your records would hold up, or the IRS has already filed a return for you, message me.
I help with IRS, New York, New Jersey, Connecticut and Pennsylvania tax problems.
General info, not advice for your specific case.