A client of mine owed New York State about $5,000.
She had about $5,000 in each of three accounts, at three different banks. The New York State Department of Taxation and Finance levied all three.
That's roughly $15,000 frozen on a $5,000 debt.
The State later refunded the overpayment. But in the meantime, the money she needed for rent, groceries and bills was stuck, all over one debt.
People always ask me the same thing: how is that allowed? Here's how a New York State bank levy happens, what to do when it hits, and how the IRS handles the same situation.
How New York State gets to a bank levy: the tax warrant
New York's collection unit gets involved when a bill goes unpaid and the appeal deadline has passed, or you've used up your appeal rights. Before filing a tax warrant, the Tax Department says it will send you notice of the debt and give you a chance to resolve it.
If the debt isn't resolved, the Department can file a tax warrant. In its own words, a tax warrant "is equivalent to a civil judgment against you." It's filed electronically with the New York State Department of State and the county clerk, it becomes a public record, and it creates a lien against your real and personal property. You get a copy.
The Department must file a tax warrant before it serves a levy. After that, its collection tools include:
- Bank levies. A levy is "a legal seizure of your property." It requires a bank or other third party holding your money to turn it over to pay your tax warrant.
- Income executions. New York's version of wage garnishment. The Department asks you to pay up to 10% of your gross wages each time you're paid, with the first payment within 20 days of the notice. If you don't, it sends the income execution to your employer.
- Other actions, including refund offsets, property seizures, driver's license suspension and private debt collection.
A New York State bank levy on multiple accounts: why every bank froze the full amount
Each levy tells a bank how much the State is collecting. Each bank only sees its own levy. None of them knows what the other two banks are holding.
So each bank can freeze up to the full amount, and the total frozen can be two or three times what you actually owe.
Under the Tax Department's levy rules, the bank has 90 days to respond. It can send the funds (up to the full amount requested), report that there are no funds, report that the account holds only exempt funds, or say that a turnover order is required. The Department says that once the bank responds, any remaining funds in the account should usually be available to you again.
In her case, the State was owed about $5,000 and collected far more. The overpayment came back later. Later doesn't help when the bills are due now.
What I'd tell anyone in this spot
1. Act fast. Don't wait for the banks to respond on their own timeline. Call the Tax Department as soon as you see the first levy.
2. Gather the paperwork. Get the levy notice from every bank, plus current statements showing exactly what each one froze.
3. Call the Tax Department about the levy. The Department's levy page says that to resolve a levy, you need to call 518-457-5893 during regular business hours and speak with a representative. Have your taxpayer ID ready. Show the total frozen across all banks against what's actually owed.
4. Deal with the balance. Pay it in full, or ask about an installment payment agreement. Under the Department's collection rights, the Tax Commissioner may release a levy if it creates undue hardship, if proper procedures weren't followed, if you have an installment agreement that provides for release, or if releasing it will help collect the debt or is in the best interest of both you and the State. A tax warrant stays on file as a lien until the warranted balance is paid in full, even with a payment plan.
5. Check what's in the accounts. Some money is protected. See the next section.
If the Department determines a levy or seizure was unjust, it may return the money seized plus interest.
Is Social Security protected from a New York State levy?
The Tax Department lists money that may be exempt from being taken to satisfy a tax warrant, including Social Security and Supplemental Security Income, public assistance, spousal support, maintenance or child support, unemployment, disability or workers' compensation benefits, and public or private pensions. The complete list is in New York Civil Practice Law and Rules (CPLR) Article 52.
Federal rules (31 CFR Part 212) also require banks to protect certain federal benefits from garnishment, and that includes a levy issued by a State or State agency. When a bank gets a levy, it must review the account. If Social Security, VA, federal retirement (OPM) or Railroad Retirement benefits were directly deposited during the two months before the review, the bank must protect that amount, or the account balance if it's lower. It does this automatically. You don't have to ask.
Money above that amount, or benefits that were deposited earlier or by check, may still be exempt, but you may need to claim it.
How an IRS bank levy compares
The IRS can also levy more than one bank at the same time. But federal law gives you more structure.
Notice first. Under IRC section 6330, the IRS generally can't levy until it notifies you in writing of your right to a hearing, at least 30 days before the first levy. That's the final notice of intent to levy, usually Letter LT11 or Letter 1058. If you ask for a hearing in time, the levy action is generally put on hold while the hearing is pending.
A 21-day hold. Under section 6332(c), a bank can surrender your deposits to the IRS only after 21 days from the date the levy was served. That's your window to work it out.
Required releases. Section 6343(a)(1) says the IRS must release a levy, in whole or in part, when:
- the tax is paid, or it's past the time to collect it
- releasing it will help collect the tax
- you enter into an installment agreement, unless the agreement says otherwise
- the levy is causing an economic hardship
- the property's fair market value is more than the tax owed, and releasing part of it won't hurt collection
That last one covers the over-levy problem. A release doesn't stop the IRS from levying again later if the balance isn't dealt with.
The fix is the same either way
Whether it's New York State or the IRS, the steps don't change much. Move quickly. Document everything. Talk to the agency as soon as the levy hits. And have a plan for the balance, because that's what gets levies released.
FAQ
Can New York State levy more than one bank account for the same debt?
Yes. Each bank only sees its own levy, so each can freeze up to the full amount. Call the Tax Department at 518-457-5893 to resolve the levy, and show what every bank is holding.
What is a New York State tax warrant?
It's the State's equivalent of a civil judgment for an unpaid tax debt. It's filed with the Department of State and the county clerk, becomes a public record and creates a lien on your property. The Department must file one before it can levy a bank account or issue an income execution.
How long does a bank have to respond to a New York State levy?
The Tax Department says the bank must respond within 90 days by sending funds, reporting no funds or only exempt funds, or advising that a turnover order is required.
What is an income execution?
It's New York's wage garnishment. You're asked to pay up to 10% of your gross wages each payday, starting within 20 days of the notice. If you don't, the Department sends it to your employer.
Is Social Security protected from a bank levy?
Directly deposited Social Security, VA, federal retirement and Railroad Retirement benefits from the two months before the bank's review are protected automatically, up to the account balance. New York also lists Social Security and other benefits as exempt from levy under CPLR Article 52.
How long before a bank sends levied money to the IRS?
Under section 6332(c), the bank can surrender the funds only after 21 days from when the levy was served.
Does the IRS have to release a levy that takes too much?
It must release a levy in whole or in part in certain cases, including when the property's value is more than the tax owed and a partial release won't hurt collection.
Related: New York tax warrant help · IRS bank levy help · IRS lien vs. levy · NYS driver's license suspension for tax debt
Official sources: NYS Tax Department: Levies · NYS Tax Department: Tax warrants · NYS Tax Department: Income executions · NYS: Your rights during the collection process · IRS: Information about bank levies · IRS: How do I get a levy released?
If a New York State or IRS levy just hit your accounts, message me, call (718) 510-3166, or book a free consultation.
I help with IRS, New York, New Jersey, Connecticut and Pennsylvania tax problems.
General info, not advice for your specific case.